Skip to content
Twitter
Facebook
Instagram
Pinterest
We're your one-stop gift shop for everyone on your list, including you! Free domestic shipping on orders over $100, load up that cart!
Shop Our Categories
Shop All
Accessories
Arts & Crafts
Astrology & Tarot
Baby & Toddler
Bar
Beauty
Books
Candles
Candy
Cleaning
Fun & Games
General Store
Gift Cards
Hand Cream
Home & Garden
Jewelry
Kids & Tweens
Kitchen
Mugs
Paper & Cards
Party Supplies
Pet Parade
Planners & Journals
Puzzles
Sheet Masks
Socks
Tools & Gadgets
Wellness
Shop Our Curations
Brooklyn Love
Featured In
Foodie
Great Outdoors
Host & Hostess Gifts
Housewarming & Thank You
Moroccan Hues
Mother's Day
Passover
Pop Culture
Rainbow Vibes
Shop Local
Shop the Rainbow
Spring Garden
Summer Brights
Sustainable Solutions
Teacher Appreciation
Travel
What's New
Gifts For All
Baby & Toddler
Kids & Tweens
Host & Hostess
Housewarming & Thank You
Gifts for Him
Gifts for Her
Bride To Be
Teacher Appreciation
Corporate Gifts
Gift Cards
What's New
Annie's Subscriptions
Puzzles
Fun, family-friendly jigsaw puzzles in a variety of sizes for all ages!
Sort by:
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Submit
1000 Piece Bodega Cat | New Yorker Jigsaw Puzzle
$26.00
1000 Piece Sidewalk Connoisseurs | New Yorker Jigsaw Puzzle
$26.00
1000 Piece The New York Diner Jigsaw Puzzle
$44.00
Box of Bagels 45 Piece Mini Jigsaw Puzzles (Set of 12)
$40.00
1000 Piece Puzzle Field Day Jigsaw Puzzle
$44.00
1000 Piece Sugar & Spice Double-Sided Jigsaw Puzzle
$44.00
1000 Piece Village by the Sea | New Yorker Jigsaw Puzzle
$22.00
500 Piece Double Parked | New Yorker Jigsaw Puzzle
$24.00
500 Piece The 100 Most Jewish Foods Circular Jigsaw Puzzle
$19.95
500 Piece Central Park Lark | New Yorker Jigsaw Puzzle
$24.00
500 Piece National Parks Wilderness and Wonder Jigsaw Puzzle
$27.00
Cavallini & Co. 500 Piece NYC Collage Jigsaw Puzzle
$20.00
500 Piece Better in My Day 80s Jigsaw Puzzle
$22.00
500 Piece Better in My Day 90s Jigsaw Puzzle
$22.00
36 Piece All the Feels Jigsaw Puzzle
$28.00
36 Piece Easy as 1, 2, 3 Jigsaw Puzzle
$28.00
20 Piece Big Cats Jigsaw Puzzle
$12.00
36 Piece Llama Land Jigsaw Puzzle To Go
$9.99
20 Piece Axolotl Jigsaw Puzzle
$12.00
3 Month Annie's Puzzle Subscription
$30.00
6 Month Annie's Puzzle Subscription
$28.00
12 Month Annie's Puzzle Subscription
$26.00
Monthly Annie's Puzzle Subscription
$26.00
1000 Piece Puzzle Buns Out Jigsaw Puzzle
$44.00
1000 Piece Gray Malin Coney Island Jigsaw Puzzle
$24.99
1000 Piece Vibrant Seashells Jigsaw Puzzle
$17.99
x
Powered by Propel Subscriptions