Skip to content
Twitter
Facebook
Instagram
Pinterest
We're your one-stop gift shop for everyone on your list, including you! Free domestic shipping on orders over $100, load up that cart!
Shop Our Categories
Shop All
Accessories
Arts & Crafts
Astrology, Tarot & Crystals
Baby & Toddler
Bar
Beauty
Books
Candles
Candy
Cleaning
Fun & Games
General Store
Gift Cards
Hand Cream
Home & Garden
Jewelry
Kids & Tweens
Kitchen
Mugs
Paper & Cards
Party Supplies
Pet
Planners & Journals
Puzzles
Sheet Masks
Socks
Tools & Gadgets
Wellness
Shop Our Curations
Back to School
Brooklyn Love
Featured In
Foodie
Great Outdoors
Host & Hostess Gifts
Housewarming & Thank You
Mahj Goodies
Pet Parade
Rainbow Vibes
Shop Local
Shop the Rainbow
Sustainable Solutions
Travel
Verdant Grove
Wedding Gifts
What's New
Gifts For All
Housewarming & Thank You
Host & Hostess
Baby & Toddler
Wedding
Kids & Tweens
Gifts for Her
Gifts for Him
Bride To Be
Graduation
Teacher Appreciation
Corporate Gifts
Gift Cards
What's New
Annie's Subscriptions
Events
Candy
Sort by:
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Submit
UP-UP Sweet Orange Milk Chocolate Bar
$12.00
UP-UP Dark Wild Mint Chocolate Bar
$12.00
BonBon Sour Peach Fish
$9.00
BonBon Sweet Wild Strawberry Fish
$9.00
BonBon Sour Blackberry Fish
$9.00
Smarties Mega Roll
$3.00
OTHERLY Sea Salt Oatmilk Chocolate Bar
$10.00
OTHERLY Cold Brew Coffee Oatmilk Chocolate Bar
$10.00
Crispy Milk Chocolate Pumpkin Balls
$4.50
Surprise Me! Candy Assortment
$10.00
Sugarfina Champagne Bears Candy Cube
$10.00
Sugarfina Rainbow Bears Candy Cube
$10.00
BonBon Sour Elderflower Fish
$9.00
BonBon Sour Wild Strawberry Fish
$9.00
OTHERLY Salted Caramel Oatmilk Chocolate Bar
$10.00
Very Cherry Candy Kittens | Gummy Candy
$9.00
Wild Strawberry Candy Kittens | Gummy Candy
$9.00
Sour Watermelon Candy Kittens | Gummy Candy
$9.00
Tuck's Cookie French Chocolate Truffles
$24.00
Haribo Rainbow Worms Gummi Candy
$4.00
Chevaliers d'Argouges Dark Chocolate Fish in Sardine Tin
$16.00
x
Powered by Propel Subscriptions